Selling a Secondary Property in the U.S.: Do You Need to File Taxes if the Sale Price is Under $300,000?

Understanding the Tax Implications of Selling a Property in the U.S. as a Canadian

If you are Canadian, and as a prudent owner of a secondary residence in the United States, you are contemplating selling it, you have likely been besieged with rumors, stories, and urban legends about the infamous $300,000 threshold. Are you among those who believe that a selling price below this amount would grant you the superpower to avoid certain U.S. tax obligations? Hold onto your maple syrup, because we are here to deconstruct, clarify, and shed some light on this fiscal saga.

Basic Rules of Real Estate Taxation in the U.S. for Canadians

First, let’s clarify the basics. The United States, in their inexhaustible fiscal wisdom, have the Internal Revenue Code (IRC). Simply put, this IRC requires that everyone, yes, everyone — even that distant cousin from Quebec — pays taxes on the capital gains from the sale of a property in the U.S. And how is this capital gain calculated? By taking the selling price and subtracting what you initially paid, transaction fees, and major improvements or renovations. No witchcraft here, just simple math.

Demystifying the $300,000 Threshold in U.S. Real Estate Taxation

Ah, the infamous $300,000 threshold, the source of so many rumors around coffee machines and picnic tables. So, is it a backdoor escape from the American tax ogre? Not exactly. This threshold actually stems from FIRPTA, the Foreign Investment in Real Property Tax Act. This law states that a 15% withholding is typically applied unless the price is under $300,000 and the buyer solemnly pledges (under oath) that they intend to reside there for at least 50% of the next two years. But beware, this exception does not turn you into a tax ninja, as you still have to declare capital gains. A selling price under $300,000 might allow you to avoid a withholding at the time of the transaction, or in other words, to receive the entire selling price when the sale concludes. That’s all!

The Importance of Declaring Capital Gains in the U.S. and Canada

Indeed, whether you sell your house for $299,999 or for an amount that resembles a lottery jackpot, the capital gain must be declared. Yes, it’s an unavoidable step in the process. It’s crucial to report any transaction, as that is the will of the American Tax Empire. If you feel overwhelmed, it’s always wise to consult a tax advisor.

Remember, if you are a Canadian resident for tax purposes (in short, if you file your taxes on the side of the maple leaf), the calculation of capital gain must be conducted in both countries. Don’t forget that the foreign exchange gain or loss on the conversion rate between the two countries’ currencies could lead to very different outcomes on each side of the border. However, if you owe a sum to the United States after calculating the capital gain and applying the personal exemption, there’s no need to worry. Indeed, the tax treaty between the two countries ensures that any amount retained by the U.S. tax authorities will be fully credited against your Canadian taxes. In short, filing taxes in both countries does not mean additional taxes to pay. However, you must ensure everything is well-coordinated during the tax season.

Risks of Non-Compliance with U.S. Tax Obligations

The solution for many Canadian sellers of U.S. properties under $300,000 is to sweep everything under the rug and focus only on the Canadian side of taxes. However, playing hide-and-seek with the taxman is a very bad idea. Failing to declare can be costly. The IRS, with its eagle-eyed vision and extended tentacles, is skilled at spotting those trying to slip through the net. It’s better not to play this game.

Successfully Navigating U.S. Real Estate Taxation

Selling a property in the U.S., even as a Canadian, requires diligence and attention. Remember, each threshold, each exception, each rule has its rationale. But with a bit of preparation and perhaps the help of a professional, you can successfully navigate these waters and sell your property while staying in the good graces of the IRS. Good luck, and may the fiscal force be with you!


Table of Contents

On Key

More goodreads from us

Start your US tax filing process the right way.

Simply complete this form and we’ll quickly be in touch.

Privacy Policy: All information submitted to Snowbird Taxes will be treated confidentially. Your personal information will not be sold or shared with anyone, including any business related to Snowbird Taxes.

Commencez votre processus de déclaration d'impôts aux États-Unis de la bonne manière.

Il vous suffit de remplir ce formulaire et nous vous contacterons rapidement.

Politique de confidentialité : Toutes les informations soumises à Snowbird Taxes seront traitées de manière confidentielle. Vos informations personnelles ne seront ni vendues ni partagées avec qui que ce soit, y compris toute entreprise liée à Snowbird Taxes.